Skip to content
Comical Opinions
Menu
  • Comic Book Reviews
  • Comic Opinions
  • How We Rate
  • Videos
  • Check Out Our Newsletter
  • Advertising
  • Contact
Menu
Midnight X-Men 2 featured image

Midnight X-Men #2 Review – Anti-Verisimilitude Vampires

Posted on November 18, 2026

Midnight X-Men #2 (Marvel, 11/18/26): Writer Jonathan Hickman and artist Matteo Della Fonte go back in time by ten years to witness the creation of the first Empyre. Hickman’s script centers on Cyclops as the nexus between the living and the dead, but you have to suspend quite a lot of disbelief to get there. Verdict: It’s fine if you turn your brain off.

Credits:

  • Writer: Jonathan Hickman
  • Artist: Matteo Della Fonte
  • Colorist: Arthur Hesli
  • Letterer: VC’s Cory Petit
  • Cover Artist: Dike Ruan, Moreno DiNisio (cover A)
  • Publisher: Marvel Comics
  • Release Date: November 18, 2026
  • Comic Rating: Mature
  • Cover Price: $4.99
  • Page Count: 24
  • Format: Single Issue

Covers:

Midnight X-Men 2 cover A
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 cover B
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 cover C
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 cover D
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 cover A
Midnight X-Men 2 cover B
Midnight X-Men 2 cover C
Midnight X-Men 2 cover D

Analysis of Midnight X-Men #2:

First Impressions:

My first reaction after reading this issue was, “C’mon, man. Really?”

Recap:

Midnight X-Men #2 established a world where vampirism had reshaped New York City, with ancient vampire clans, new vampires, the Holy Roman Church, mutants, and the Empyres maintaining a fragile peace through an uneasy treaty. When a codex hunting vampire nests was slaughtered by a group of Reavers, Magneto sent word to Cyclops to rescue the lone survivor, a young girl named Hope, while Gambit and his Empyre team moved to eliminate the Reavers and claim her for themselves. Cyclops arrived to help Hope escape, while Bishop Kurt Wagner warned the Empyres’ leader about Cardinal Stryker’s orders to hunt vampires, revealing that the mysterious leader was none other than Storm.

Plot Analysis (SPOILERS):

The issue begins with narration from Vlad Dracula, explaining a brief bit of his history, from his parents to the vampire who made him the monster he is today. Burdened with immortality, he found a new spark in life when he learned of the existence of mutants. His first sire? Ororo, who simply submitted to Dracula without so much as a harsh word.

Worried for their missing teammate, the X-Men rush to Transylvania when Cerebro picks up Ororo’s signal weeks later. When the team enters the castle, they’re quickly separated and turned, including Phoenix and Iceman. Only Kitty Pryde and Cyclops escape. Later, Phoenix, aka Jean Grey, psychically reaches out to Cyclops for help. In turn, Cyclops goes to Professor X, but the professor refuses, citing risk. Cyclops then reaches out to Magneto for help, who also refuses due to the risk.

Cyclops goes rogue (no pun intended) and storms Dracula’s castle again with another team, who all succumb with barely a fight. Through his love and despair, Jean sends Cyclops off to bring other mutants to Dracula for turning. Years later, Cyclops breaks out of his mental delusion and decides to destroy the vampires… in the name of love.

How is the story in Midnight X-Men #2?

C’mon, man, really? What are we doing here? Jonathan Hickman dedicates the second issue in this new imprint to explaining how a segment of the mutant population became vampires, which is good. We needed more of that background, which was missing from the first issue, to understand how the world got into the state it’s in. But instead of coming up with a clever or surprising way to explain the creation of Empyres that you can believe, his explanation boils down to “they got bit.”

Why is this a problem? Consider the characters. Iceman – a mutant who can encase himself (or is, if you take the elemental interpretation) – just got bit. Jean Grey, aka Phoenix – the world’s most powerful telekinetic and the human host of the Phoenix force – just got bit. Ororo, aka Storm – mutant with complete control over the weather elements and revered in some countries as a goddess – just willingly allowed herself to get bit.

As soon as you get past the second page and say to yourself, “What? There’s no way that could happen like that, and certainly not that easily,” the rest of the issue falls apart, no matter how sincere and tragic Cyclops’ dilemma. Hickman needed to explain how the world he created came to be, and he did it in the laziest, most unbelievable way possible.

How is the art in Midnight X-Men #2?

Matteo Della Fonte is doing the Lord’s work in this issue. The panel layouts lean into deep, heavy shadows, contrasted with hyper-saturated monochrome washes to give the bloodletting an old-school, cinematic vibe, reminiscent of Giallo films and a 1970s horror aesthetic. Visually, Midnight X-Men #2 is super moody and much more atmospheric compared to the first issue, which is a big plus. The art saves the ridiculousness of Hickman’s script.

Characters

Despite the plethora of familiar characters, Cyclops is the tragic heart of this issue. Scott spirals from stoic group leader to desperate lover trying to save his beloved to broken man to warrior out for revenge. To be fair to Hickman, Scott’s emotional journey is powerfully portrayed, even if the circumstances that bring about his misery don’t make sense.

Originality & Concept Execution

Well, if you needed an explanation as to how mutants were turned into vampires, this is it. That said, prior variations on this theme have been done much better (see X-Men Annual #6). Furthermore, even without prior, better issues to point to, that doesn’t excuse the lack of believability in the execution.

Pros and Cons

What We Loved
  • Moody, creepy art by Della Fonte
  • Scott’s downward spiral is emotionally tragic
  • This issue explains how we got here
Room for Improvement
  • The downfall of the mutants is wholly unbelievable
  • Scott’s choice to follow his heart is also unbelievable (as presented)
  • The data pages are immaterial to the story and waste space

Art Samples:

Midnight X-Men 2 preview 1
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 preview 2
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 preview 3
No Caption
Midnight X-Men 2 preview 1
Midnight X-Men 2 preview 2
Midnight X-Men 2 preview 3

The Scorecard:

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): 1.5/4
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): 3.5/4
Value (Originality & Entertainment): 0.5/2

Final Thoughts:

(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)

Midnight X-Men #2 explains how the vampires took over the world ten years ago. Unfortunately, Jonathan Hickman’s script presents the tragic downfall with a wholly unbelievable, almost lazy attempt at an explanation. Thankfully, Matteo Della Fonte’s moody, atmospheric aesthetic ramps up the horror vibes for a beautiful, if not dumb, issue.

Score: 5.5/10

★★★★★★★★★★

Related Posts:

  • Blade Runner: Tokyo Nexus #1 featured image
    BLADE RUNNER: TOKYO NEXUS #1 – New Comic Review
  • Blade Runner: Tokyo Nexus #2 featured image
    BLADE RUNNER: TOKYO NEXUS #2 – New Comic Review
  • Midnight X-Men 1 featured image
    Midnight X-Men #1 Review – Blood Hunt, Part 2
  • Midnight Fantastic Four 1 featured image
    Midnight Fantastic Four #1 Review – Lovecraftian…
  • Midnight Spider-Man 1 featured image
    Midnight Spider-Man #1 Review – More Same Than Different


We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media: 

Connect With Us Here

If you’re interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.


As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.

Related Posts:

  • Conan Tides of the Tyrant King 3 featured image
    Conan: Tides of the Tyrant King #3 Review - Costigan…
  • Chainkata 1 featured image
    Chainkata #1 Review - A Unique, Gore-Soaked Space Opera
  • Midnight Spider-Man 2 featured image
    Midnight Spider-Man #2 Review - The Monster In The Dark
  • Midnight Fantastic Four 2 featured image
    Midnight Fantastic Four #2 Review - A Slow Stroll To…

–More For Free–

  • Check Out Our Newsletter

Check Out Our Partners

Jooble - Find Comic Artist Jobs
©2026 Comical Opinions | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme