Batman #12 Review – Alfred’s Replacement Arrives In Time For An Assassin Gathering

Batman #12 (DC Comics, 8/5/26): Writer Matt Fraction and Artist Jorge Jimenez introduce the world to Verity Pennyworth, the great-niece of Alfred, and an asset who proves to be quickly valuable. Fans of Alfred Pennyworth may bemoan this confirmation that he’s not coming back, but Verity has potential. Verdict: Speculator alert for a first appearance, but the plot is a nothing burger.

• Writer: Matt Fraction
• Artist: Jorge Jimenez
• Colorist: Tomeu Morey
• Letterer: Clayton Cowles
• Cover Artist: Jorge Jimenez (cover A)
• Publisher: DC Comics
• Release Date: August 5, 2026
• Comic Rating: Teen
• Cover Price: $4.99
• Page Count: 28
• Format: Single Issue

Covers:

Analysis of Batman #12:

First Impressions:

The only reason to read Batman #12 is to get a gander at the first appearance of Alfred’s replacement, Verity Pennyworth. She’s smart and effective, which is all you could ask for. However, the plot fails to move the needle.

Recap:

Batman #11 concluded Batman’s fight against the deadly blades of Ōjō, but Commissioner Vandal Savage made sure the full force of the GCPD was leveled against the Caped Crusader. The issue ended with a mysterious woman showing up on Bruce Wayne’s doorstep.

Plot Analysis (SPOILERS):

Batman #12 begins with Bruce having a heart-to-heart with his imaginary Alfred to ascertain if Verity Pennyworth truly is who she says she is – Alfred Pennyworth’s great-niece and trained successor. Imaginary Alfred confirms the existence of a secret society – The Society of the Midnight Key – which functions to train people like Alfred to support people like Batman. Verity was born and bred for her job as Alfred’s replacement.

Meanwhile, a collection of eclectic and colorful assassins arrive in Gotham City at roughly the same time. Through a tiny bit of deduction, Batman learns they were summoned to kill Bruce Wayne. Batman intervenes in a fight between two of the assassins, a fight that Batman learned Verity helped to coordinate. The issue ends with the Joker receiving an unexpected visitor.

How is the story in Batman #12?

Matt Fraction’s attempt at replacing Alfred works well enough. Verity is charming, extremely capable, resourceful, and, let’s be honest, easy on the eyes. In an ideal world, DC would find a way to resurrect Alfred (or retcon his pointless death in the first place), but if Alfred is gone for good, Verity is a welcome addition. That said, all the information Bruce learns about Verity’s background and The Society of the Midnight Key comes from his delusional recreation of Alfred in his mind, which doesn’t make sense. It’s one thing to conjure Alfred to create a reassuring voice. It’s another to actively get new information from said delusion, and Fraction overreaches on this point.

The rest of the plot, if you could call it that, is where the issue falls short. Fraction creates an eclectic cast of unusual assassins, each with specific talents, but Fraction does nothing with them other than introduce them in a montage of vignettes. It looks and feels a lot like Tynion’s run wherein he introduced a rash of villains that have since been forgotten (Does anyone remember The Gardener or Miracle Molly?). In effect, Fraction’s script paints by numbers with stories we’ve already seen before, and it just doesn’t do anything except exist. No hype. No buzz. No wow moments other than a brief fight.

Lastly, Joker (still suspended in a fluid chamber) receives a visit from a disembodied voice. The scene generates some anticipation but doesn’t pay it off, so Fraction writes a lot of stuff that goes nowhere and accomplishes very little.

How is the art in Batman #12?

Jorge Jimenez’s artwork is the bright spot of the issue. The character expressions look great, which is a must in a dialog-heavy issue. Jimenez’s Batman renderings are phenomenal. The brief elevator fight is solid. And Tomeu Morey’s coloring is outstanding. You can complain about the script, but the art is top tier.

Characters

Bruce Wayne is the focal point of this issue, with Damian taking up a strong second place. We see Bruce wrestling with the notion of “saying goodbye” to Alfred, his reluctant acceptance of Verity when she proves herself, and his private expression of fondness for Damian. Likewise, Damian, the rascally rascal, proves his mental prowess by profiling the assassins and taking a shine to Verity almost immediately. On the whole, the blossoming dynamic between the three is sweet.

Originality & Concept Execution

The originality in Batman #12 is a mixed bag. Verity’s introduction is a from-scratch setup that could have been formulated in ten different ways, but Fraction decides to play it straight with excellent execution. On the other hand, a collective of competing assassins showing up in Gotham City is about as unoriginal as it gets.

Pros and Cons

What We Loved

• Fantastic art
• Verity Pennyworth’s assimilation is solid
• The brief moments of humor land well

Room for Improvement

• The “assassins come to Gotham” setup is tired
• Joker’s visitor scene ends in a clunky cliffhanger with zero hype
• Alfred’s insights don’t make any sense

Art Samples:

The Scorecard:

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): 2.5/4
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): 3.5/4
Value (Originality & Entertainment): 1/2

Final Thoughts:

(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)

Batman #12 introduces the world to Alfred’s replacement – Verity Pennyworth. Matt Fraction’s script gives the latest addition to the Bat-family a strong start, and Jorge Jimenez’s art is some of the best at DC. That said, everything about the comic, outside of Verity’s introduction, is tired and flat.

---

---

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.