Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2 Review – Descent Into the Cellar

Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2 (Image Comics, 3/25/26): Writer Tyler Boss and artist Martin Simmonds deliver a haunting horror as Christine Daaé faces threats after a murder. Atmosphere is masterful. Verdict: A must-read for gothic horror fans.

• Writer: Tyler Boss
• Artist: Martin Simmonds
• Colorist: Martin Simmonds
• Letterer: Uncredited
• Cover Artist: Martin Simmonds (cover A)
• Publisher: Image Comics
• Release Date: March 25, 2026
• Comic Rating: Teen
• Cover Price: $4.99
• Page Count: 28
• Format: Single Issue

Covers:

Analysis of Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2:

First Impressions:

Look, we’ve all seen the Phantom story before, but this one feels different from the usual retellings. From the first page, the art pulls you into a hazy version of Paris where the shadows feel like they have teeth. There is a real weight to the dread that makes the grand opera house feel like a gilded trap. It does not try too hard to scream for your attention. Instead, it lets a cold feeling of fear sit in your stomach while the story unfolds.

Recap:

After the brutal murder of the diva Biancarolli in Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #1, the Paris Opera House is a tinderbox of paranoia and ghosts. Christine Daaé received a chilling warning to leave, yet she remains entangled in the theater’s dark politics and her own rising career. Inspector Dubert is digging for a motive while the Phantom’s influence grows in the shadows. Now, Christine must survive the theater’s literal and metaphorical depths to keep her life.

Plot Analysis (SPOILERS):

One week after the opening night tragedy, Christine Daaé moves toward the spotlight while trying to leave her past life behind. She meets Inspector Dubert on the street, where he saves her from a fan who appears to be following her for an autograph. Their talk shows that they still have a deep connection, even as Dubert fails to find a motive for the murder. Christine invites him to her debut, but she is unaware that the Phantom is tracking her every move from the rooftops.

The mood turns dark when Megan lures Christine into a deep storage cellar under the guise of the Maestro’s orders. Christine finds herself locked in the pitch black room where she is suddenly attacked by a massive swarm of aggressive rats. She is saved just in time by Monsieur Garron and Anatole, but the trauma of the attack leaves her shaking as the curtain is about to rise. Despite the fear, she is pushed back toward the stage where her journey to greatness continues.

How is the story in Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2?

Tyler Boss masterfully accelerates the tension by focusing on the quiet moments that build the dread. The dialogue feels real and grounded, avoiding the typical melodrama found in most gothic horror stories. This issue delivers on the basics of a strong story by giving Christine a clear goal and putting huge obstacles in her path. Her journey into the basement raises the stakes from her career to her life, keeping the focus on her as the main character. The pacing is slow at first, but it builds to a scary finish that leaves you wanting more.

How is the art in Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2?

Martin Simmonds is a master of mood, and his art in this issue is unlike anything else on the stands. He uses messy, painterly strokes and chaotic colors to create a world that looks like a beautiful nightmare. The way he draws the rat swarm in the cellar is very effective because it makes the reader feel just as trapped as Christine. His use of light helps tell the story by showing us exactly what the characters are afraid of in the dark.

The faces in this book tell a story of their own, as Simmonds captures the fear and worry of the cast with a light touch. You can see the panic in Christine’s eyes and the focus on Dubert’s face without reading a single word. His layouts flow well, moving the eye through the haze of the theater’s underbelly with ease. The final result is a visual experience that feels both huge and very personal. Every page looks like a piece of art that you could hang on your wall.

Characters

Christine is not just a victim in this story. She is a woman with a clear goal, and she is willing to risk a lot to get what she wants. We see her growing more confident, even as the world around her gets more dangerous. Dubert is a good hero because he is just a man trying to do his job in a world that makes no sense. The way they interact feels honest and adds a lot of heart to a story that is mostly about shadows and death.

Originality & Concept Execution

This is a fresh take on a story we all know, and it works because it leans into the horror. The idea of the Phantom as a ghost story is a great hook that sets it apart from other versions. It delivers on the promise of a scary monster book while still giving us a plot that feels like a classic mystery. The team has taken a legendary character and made him feel scary again for a new generation.

Pros and Cons

What We Loved

• The messy, painterly art style creates a deep sense of gothic dread and unease in every panel.
• Grounded dialogue makes the characters feel like real people facing a scary nightmare.
• The cellar scene is a perfect mix of psychological fear and physical horror that hits hard.

Room for Improvement

• The middle of the book slows down a bit too much before the big climax in the cellar.
• Some side characters feel like they are only there to move the plot along for the lead.
• A few scene changes feel a little fast, making the timeline of events slightly confusing.

Art Samples:

The Scorecard:

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): 3.5/4
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): 3.5/4
Value (Originality & Entertainment): 1.5/2

Final Thoughts:

(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)

Universal Monsters: The Phantom of the Opera #2 is a masterclass in atmospheric horror that earns its place on any serious pull list through sheer visual audacity. The breathtakingly macabre art and grounded character work ensure every page drips with genuine tension. Minor pacing hiccups and thin side characters are the only small blemishes on an otherwise stellar production. Ultimately, this issue proves that some ghosts are worth chasing, offering a deeply rewarding experience for anyone who values substance over surface-level jumpscares. Does this comic earn a place in a limited budget? Absolutely.

---

---

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.