Supernatural #1, by Dynamite Comics on 10/29/25, drops Sam and Dean Winchester into a small-town brewery facing spontaneous human combustion and even weirder spirits.
Credits:
- Writer: Greg Pak
- Artist: Eder Messias
- Colorist: Thyago Brandao
- Letterer: Jeff Eckleberry
- Cover Artist: Clayton Crain (cover A)
- Publisher: Dynamite Comics
- Release Date: October 29, 2025
- Comic Rating: Teen
- Cover Price: $4.99
- Page Count: 26
- Format: Single Issue
Covers:
Analysis of SUPERNATURAL #1:
First Impressions:
Supernatural #1 wallows in brotherly baggage and bad omens, tossing Sam and Dean headfirst into a mystery loaded with enough fire to scorch their already frayed nerves. The script wastes no time in setting the boys against both monsters and management, with the art keeping pace, sometimes tripping over its own urgency but never slowing down. If demonic imps don’t get you, the puns will.
Plot Analysis:
Sam and Dean Winchester, still smarting from old demons and new debts, get wind of a bizarre death in Windler, Michigan. A man combusts mysteriously at work, with the only witness being his widow and a surly brewery staff. Dean jokes, Sam broods, and someone’s always trying to dodge a bad credit card charge between haunting scenes.
The investigation at Windler Breweries uncorks family drama, workplace backstabbing, and rumors of spontaneous human combustion. The victim’s widow, Gloria, blames cursed liquor and an ungrateful employer, while brewery employee Effie offers more salt than answers. Softball ghost-hunting nods soon collide with the real thing: Sam’s visions, a whiff of brimstone, and a secret about trapping imps in whiskey bottles.
Pushed to the limit, Sam and Dean confront the supernatural culprit: a demon-spawn imp unleashed by greed, now targeting anyone left standing. Dean cracks wise while Sam nearly dooms himself with heroic stubbornness. Salt lines, enchanted bottles, and iron rods fly until the brothers outwit their foe in classic Winchester style.
Effie’s real identity is revealed as Steff Windler, cunning CEO of Windler Enterprises. The price of trapping the imp – eternal damnation for the captor – was one the CEO cheerfully pawned off on others. Sam and Dean leave with more questions than answers (and still no motel money), wondering how to win in a world where rules are meant for breaking and the worst people walk free.
Story
Greg Pak’s script nails the Winchester banter, flinging sibling insults and sharp jabs at every page turn. The pacing slams forward without offering much time for reflection, echoing the show’s fast-and-loose approach but sometimes sacrificing clarity for quips. Plot twists feel true to the Supernatural brand as equal parts noir and nerdy, but the issue occasionally stumbles, cramming exposition and monster lore into conversations that barely breathe.
Art
Eder Messias’ art serves up mood in broad, energetic strokes. Characters are instantly recognizable, and action scenes hit with satisfying impact, even if anatomy sometimes wobbles and backgrounds blur into suggestion rather than reality. Thyago Brandao’s colors bring a burnt, autumnal tone that fits the comic’s blend of horror and humor. The visual storytelling never dithers but could use finer detail to match the script’s bite.
Characters
Sam and Dean are drawn with all their trademark friction and charm, though subtlety isn’t on tap. Secondary players like Effie/Steff add villainous spice, with enough duplicity to keep even veteran fans second-guessing which side of the salt line anyone’s on. The imp antagonist is amusingly grotesque, more clever than terrifying as a supernatural critter with teeth but hardly nightmare fuel.
Positives
The comic’s standout feature is its relentless, TV-accurate banter between Sam and Dean. The humor cuts through the gloom and doom, making the horror elements more fun than frightening. The story moves briskly, never getting bogged down in technical jargon or overwrought stakes, and the central mystery delivers enough weirdness to satisfy both old fans and first-timers alike.
Negatives
While the pacing never stalls, it often trades depth for speed. Exposition crowds dialogue, leaving secondary characters underdeveloped and some plot reveals feeling rushed. The art, while lively, sometimes lacks the precision needed to land emotional beats or sell the spookier set-pieces. Faces twist unpredictably, and settings blur in a rush to the next scare.
Art Samples:
Final Thoughts:
(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)
SUPERNATURAL #1 is a fiery, fast-talking first issue that nails the TV show’s spirit, even as it occasionally fumbles the landing. It’s a fun, breezy ride that’s light on horror but heavy on Winchester charm and whiskey-bottle stakes. When the next monster shows up, count on the brothers and their questionable credit to keep things loud and messy.
We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media:
If you’re interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.
Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com
As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.