REDCOAT #15 – New Comic Review

Redcoat #15, by Image Comics on 11/12/25, swaps muskets for measuring tape, but asks if a guy who cheats death can ever clock out for good without the bill coming due.

Credits:

• Writer: Geoff Johns
• Artist: Bryan Hitch, Andrew Currie
• Colorist: Brad Anderson
• Letterer: Rob Leigh
• Cover Artist: Bryan Hitch, Brad Anderson (cover A)
• Publisher: Image Comics
• Release Date: November 12, 2025
• Comic Rating: Teen
• Cover Price: $3.99
• Page Count: 36
• Format: Single Issue

Covers:

Analysis of REDCOAT #15:

First Impressions:

The opening splash of a bustling tailor shop in 1909 hits like a warm hug from an old coat, all golden light and quiet stitches that scream “finally, some peace” after centuries of chaos. Simon Pure’s easy grin amid the fabric scraps pulls you in fast, promising a breather from battles that feels earned and real. Yet that subtle itch of “this can’t last” lingers in every panel, turning comfort into a sly countdown to disruption.

Recap:

In Redcoat #14, in 1814 Washington D.C., immortal redcoat Simon Pure dodges arson blame amid the British torching of the White House, led by vengeful Admiral Cockburn aiming to shatter American spirit by burning key landmarks. Trapped in a card game until smoke forces a frantic exit, Simon collides with fierce First Lady Dolley Madison, who ropes him into a chaotic rescue of George Washington’s portrait through flames, brawls, and crumbling halls, their witty clashes over heroes fueling the frenzy. As thunder douses the ruins at dawn, they share a soot-streaked moment of reflection on loss and legacy, the saved painting a beacon of endurance. A modern flash-forward teases a mysterious portrait haunting today’s leaders, fueling whispers of Simon’s cursed loyalty and the Redcoat myth’s endless grip.

Plot Analysis:

In the sweltering summer of 1909 New York City, Simon Pure stitches suits in a corner tailor shop, his immortal hands now folding collars instead of bayonets. Coworkers rib him about his mysterious past over bolts of cloth, but Simon brushes it off with a laugh, content in the rhythm of needles and thread that masks his endless years. The city buzzes outside with horse carts and early autos, a far cry from the battlefields he left behind, yet Simon savors the simple grind as his best disguise yet.

After locking up, Simon stops for a bouquet of daisies from a street vendor, his steps light toward a brownstone where a little girl in ribbons flings open the door with cries of “Daddy.” Inside, his wife stirs flour for biscuits while their sons tumble in from play, the kitchen alive with spills and giggles that chase away any shadow of war. Simon scoops up his daughter for a twirl, trading tales of apple pies for the day’s small wins, his beard tickling her cheek as the family shares a meal under gaslight lamps.

That night, as rain taps the windows and his loved ones sleep tangled in quilts, Simon rises alone to pore over a dusty tome titled The Mysteries and Myths of America’s Founding Fathers. Candle flames dance across yellowed pages etched with serpents and forgotten oaths, his fingers tracing secrets that whisper of curses older than the republic. A floorboard creaks in the hall, but the house holds its breath, leaving Simon to wrestle ghosts in the quiet hours before dawn.

Come morning, his wife flips eggs while chatting about a knock at the door from the night before, dismissed as a stray cat. But when the bell chimes again, Simon finds Albert on the stoop, an old comrade with a mustache like a broom and eyes sharp as sabers. Hugs turn to urgent words over coffee, Albert pleading for help against a traitor from the grave, Benedict Arnold himself stirring in the dark with a book that burns blue. Simon balks at upending his fragile peace, but the pull of the past tightens like a noose, ending on a spectral vow that no tailor can mend.

Story

Pacing builds like a slow stitch, letting domestic beats breathe before the intrusion snaps tight in the final act, keeping twenty-two pages from dragging into nostalgia overload. Dialogue snaps with era flavor, from ribbing shop talk to family quips that land warm without syrup, advancing bonds through quick barbs and pauses. Structure layers eras smartly, using captions to weave Simon’s inner weariness into scene transitions that feel seamless, not forced.

Art

Clarity shines in crowded shop panels where every thread and face pops distinct, guiding eyes from Simon’s steady hands to the city’s haze without clutter. Composition frames intimacy tight, like the kitchen chaos bursting with tilted angles that amp joy, while wider street shots stretch tension across brick and shadow. Colors glow sepia-warm for home life, shifting to cool blues in night reads that mood-shift from safe to sinister, all syncing to amp emotional whiplash.

Characters

Simon’s motivation roots deep in craving normalcy, his every gentle dad move consistent with a man dodging eternity’s bite, making his reluctance hit relatable as a dad’s quiet fear of loss. Wife and kids stay true sketches, their easy affection mirroring Simon’s soft spots without stealing focus, building quick empathy through shared glances. Albert bursts in consistent as the spark, his pushy loyalty clashing Simon’s calm to reveal cracks in the immortal facade that beg more digs next time.

Originality & Concept Execution

The premise refreshes by plunking an undying soldier into 1909’s bustle, delivering on quiet rebellion against fate with family stakes that twist history’s echo into personal peril. Fresh hooks like the founding myths book nail the supernatural tease, succeeding in blending era details with curse lore without retreading old wars. Execution lands the “past never dies” punch through subtle buildup, turning a tailor tale into a sly setup for betrayal that feels earned, not gimmicky.

Positives

The art’s warm glow on family scenes nails emotional synergy, turning simple hugs into page-turners that boost entertainment value by making Simon’s peace feel fragile and fierce, tying straight to composition’s tight frames that heighten every laugh. Writing’s pacing masters the slow burn, delivering originality through 1909’s lived-in grit that executes the immortal domestication concept with fresh wit, ensuring dialogue’s natural flow keeps character motivations popping without a single flat beat. Those closing whispers of Arnold’s return crank the hook, blending historical freshness with plot structure that leaves you invested, proving this issue maximizes its runtime on relatable heart amid the haunt.

Negatives

Pacing’s cozy linger on home life drags just enough in mid-issue to test patience, undercutting writing clarity by padding domestic beats that don’t always advance the curse’s pull, lowering value when quicker cuts could sharpen the threat’s shadow. Character depth skimps on Albert’s backstory drop, leaving his urgency feel abrupt against Simon’s consistency, which weakens relatability and makes the reunion’s emotional synergy hit softer than the premise demands. Originality stumbles in the book’s myth reveal, executing the founding fathers tease with vague serpents that nod to lore without fresh twists, detracting from concept payoff by teasing bigger swings this setup can’t fully land yet.

Art Samples:

The Scorecard

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): 3/4
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): 4/4
Value (Originality & Entertainment): 1/2

Final Thoughts:

(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)

REDCOAT #15 trades glory for aprons smartly enough to snag your shelf space amid the stack, but only if you bet on the slow stitch paying off in bloodier threads ahead. It earns the spot for folks chasing history’s bite with family glue, yet skips the must-buy crown until the past claws deeper than a bedtime story.

---

---

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.