HARLEY QUINN X ELVIRA #2 – New Comic Review

Harley Quinn x Elvira #2, by Dynamite Comics on 11/19/25, is back to test the patience (and wallets) of Halloween junkies with its blend of chaos, confection, and a parade of questionable decisions.

Credits:

• Writer: Amanda Conner, Jimmy Palmiotti
• Artist: Amanda Conner, Juan Samu
• Colorist: Amanda Conner, Walter Pereyra
• Letterer: Dave Lanphear
• Cover Artist: Amanda Conner (cover A)
• Publisher: Dynamite Comics
• Release Date: November 19, 2025
• Comic Rating: Teen
• Cover Price: $4.99
• Page Count: 28
• Format: Single Issue

Covers:

Analysis of HARLEY QUINN X ELVIRA #2:

First Impressions:

Brace for wordy banter, hallucinogenic pastry dilemmas, and a plot that wobbles across a half-dozen boroughs without stopping for breath. The opening pages lean hard into pun-heavy dialogue and zany circumstances but leave the characters hovering just outside their classic personalities. There is instant energy, though little of it rings true to Harley or Elvira’s distinctive charm.

Recap:

In Harley Quinn X Elvira #1, Harley Quinn woke up, bickered with her pet beaver, and wrangled cookie scouts, still haunted by missing last year’s Halloween due to the flu. Determined to throw Brooklyn’s wildest Halloween bash, she recruited her oddball crew (Big Tony, Red Tool, Bernie) and set sights on enlisting Elvira, who was busy fending off puppet people eager to evict her from her penthouse after her TV show’s cancellation. The issue closed with Harley and Elvira sealing a deal to co-host, offering pie and promises as the party plans teetered between legendary status and utter disaster.

Plot Analysis:

The story opens with Harley marveling at the sunrise above Coney Island, already plotting her Halloween “anything but fun” bash while trading wisecracks about zombie-proof rooftops and pet poop projectiles. The comic wastes no time introducing Red Tool, whose flirtatious slapstick doesn’t quite spark against Harley’s personality, and Elvira touring her new crew’s animal-infested digs, gamely rolling with Brooklyn’s weirdest offers.​

Twelve hours earlier, the plot jumps to Staten Island for a sideline caper involving explosions and a grandfather launched into a neighbor’s pool, piling on slapstick mayhem with little narrative glue. Harley’s crew laments their lack of cash for Elvira’s high celebrity co-host fee, setting off a convoluted scheme to take down local mobster Boffa Fungoo – a kitchen cabinet kingpin infamous for crimes ranging from arson to pizza deification. Harley and gang decide to tackle the job mercenary-style, lacing in every culinary pun and neighborhood stereotype they can muster.​

Elvira is roped in as “cover” during a raid on Boffa Fungoo’s headquarters, donning a skin-tight costume and wielding ice cream as distraction while Harley’s team runs the more dangerous plays out back. The sabotage gets sticky, literally and figuratively, as street vendor gags and mob henchmen add to the chaos. The scheme climaxes in a botched attempt to squeeze Boffa Fungoo, with Elvira herself lamenting the tightness of her borrowed Ice Cream Server suit and barely getting any lines that would make her the “Mistress of the Dark.”

With a melee of failed gags, burnt-out storefronts, and no real sense of victory, the comic sets up its next escapade with a cliffhanger that dangles more mayhem and farce, but not much hope for actual plot fulfillment or memorable character beats.

Story

The pacing lurches between manic and meandering, with scene transitions happening so quickly that even a seasoned reader could lose their bearings. Dialogue leans into puns and frenetic comebacks but repeatedly sidesteps authentic voice, especially for Harley and Elvira. The writing feels busy, not witty, straining for laughs by drowning the characters in word salad. Structurally, the comic jumps between slapstick action and forced exposition, making the narrative hard to follow and less enjoyable for those hoping for story fundamentals.

Art

Amanda Conner brings high-energy visuals with bold lines, exaggerated expressions, and kinetic composition, but the crowded panels sometimes obscure the action or distract from emotional beats. Color is vibrant, swinging wildly from pastel chaos to neon overload, matching the mood but occasionally fighting the clarity of scenes. Panel transitions sometimes confuse rather than convey, and background details fade behind the frenzy of foreground antics.

Characters

The titular duo – Harley Quinn and Elvira – never quite step into their classic boots here. Harley’s signature mischief is lost amid convoluted side plots, and Elvira rarely offers more than generic quips and slapstick; both characters struggle to assert recognizable motivation or consistency. Relatability takes a backseat to running gags and one-liners, leaving long-time fans with little to latch onto in terms of personality or authentic dialog.

Originality & Concept Execution

The premise of a borough-wide Halloween party thrown by two cult icons is fresh, but the comic fails to capitalize on its own potential. Instead of witty genre fusion and genuine humor, readers get scattered set pieces and a reliance on tired puns and local color. Execution falters; the stated concept morphs into chaotic slapstick, losing track of its characters and failing to deliver memorable crossover moments.

Positives

What this issue does well, it does with flair: visual energy, comedic timing in select panels, and playful references to Brooklyn and Staten Island chaos keep the page-turning brisk. The setting itself, packed with pets and local oddballs, supplies enough mayhem to amuse those seeking a loud, busy comic with “where’s the plot?” energy. Fans of Amanda Conner’s expressive art and candy-colored chaos will find moments to appreciate, even if the storytelling lets them down.

Negatives

Harley Quinn x Elvira #2 stumbles in crucial areas: character authenticity is paper-thin, the humor feels forced, and the plot is more patchwork than parade. Dialogue overload and manic pacing make for a confusing read, and not even the inventive art can rescue the protagonists from their generic, interchangeable lines. Ultimately, this issue fails to deliver on its lively concept, leaving readers with little narrative clarity or valid reason to invest in the series if character depth or plot are their priorities.

Art Samples:

The Scorecard

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): [1/4]
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): [2/4]
Value (Originality & Entertainment): [1/2]

Final Thoughts:

(Click this link 👇 to order this comic)

When two genre legends collide, expectations should rise, not flatline. HARLEY QUINN X ELVIRA #2 is a sugar rush of empty calories: bright, frantic, and a little exhausting, but light on substance and star power. Save your comic budget for a title that remembers how to give its headliners something real to say and do; this one delivers puns and pets, not punch.

---

---

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.